Starred review from January 24, 2011
In a narrative that's conversational yet informative, Bildner dives into the baseball season of 1941, alternately focusing on Yankee slugger DiMaggio, who had a 56-game hitting streak, and Red Sox star Williams, who ended the season with a batting average of .406. Bildner builds suspense with taut descriptions of critical on-field moments ("...on that warm spring afternoon in the Bronx, the Streak began"), while Schindler's paintings capture the ballpark energy, with authentic period details and solid likenesses of DiMaggio, Williams, and other players. Bildner and Schindler effectively evoke the baseball fever ignited by these two performances, which established records that have yet to be broken—a fact that makes this story all the more satisfying. Ages 7–9.
Starred review from January 1, 2011
One of the joys of baseball is its intergenerational appeal. Parents and grandparents pass on tales of special games and players, and today's young fans will do the same; thus, the heroes of the past and their exploits live on. The 1941 season was especially memorable because of the amazing accomplishments of two of the greatest players of all time. That was the year the Yankees' Joe DiMaggio hit in 56 straight games and Boston's Ted Williams had a season batting average of .406. Alternating between the two stories, Bildner narrates the tale with breathless enthusiasm, capturing the excitement that swept the nation, while cleverly incorporating facts, statistics, highlights of the games and insights into the players' personalities. Modern fans are reminded of more recent players who attempted to break these records and of other records already shattered (Barry Bonds is conspicuously absent from the discussion of the lifetime homerun record). Schindler's soft, detailed ink, watercolor and gouache illustrations perfectly complement the text as they capture the mood and time period along with the action. Will there ever be such a season again? Wait 'til next year. Batter up! (Picture book. 6-12)
(COPYRIGHT (2011) KIRKUS REVIEWS/NIELSEN BUSINESS MEDIA, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.)
Starred review from March 1, 2011
Gr 3-6-This warm tribute recounts the achievements of baseball greats DiMaggio and Williams in the 1941 season. Bildner emphasizes their sportsmanship and hails their work ethic and grace under pressure. DiMaggio's 56-game hitting streak inspired songs and was followed by fans everywhere; when it came to an end, the Yankee Clipper noted that he was not happy, but relieved. And Williams chose to play on the final day of the season, even though it jeopardized his chance to keep his average above the .400 mark. Fans will relish the number of facts sprinkled throughout. Joe's younger brother, Dominic, makes an appearance: a baseball great in his own right, he was a Red Sox teammate and friend of Williams. Schindler's pen, ink, and gouache illustrations ably complement the text, and the book sports a handsome, retro look with lots of white space around the text and oversize illustrations. In an author's note, Bildner describes records set by Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, and Hank Aaron, and observes: "you never know when a player just might start a quest to bat .400 or begin a record-breaking hitting streak." This winning picture book should be welcomed by baseball enthusiasts everywhere. Even non-sports fans will appreciate how Bildner and Schindler weave period details into this engaging account of one remarkable season.-Marilyn Taniguchi, Beverly Hills Public Library, CA
Copyright 2011 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
May 1, 2011
Baseball fans know numbers, and they know these numbers: Babe Ruth's record-setting sixty-home-run season in 1927; Lou Gehrig's 2,130 consecutive games played for the New York Yankees; Babe Ruth's homerun total of 714 for his career. No one thought these records would ever be broken, but they were. Bildner decorously steps around the steroid controversies behind some of the current baseball records and notes only that Roger Maris hit sixty-one home runs in 1961, Cal Ripkin Jr. broke Gehrig's endurance record, and Hank Aaron set a new lifetime homerun record with 755. Two records, though, both set in the 1941 season, have never been broken: Joe DiMaggio hit safely in fifty-six consecutive games, and Ted Williams hit for a .406 average, considered by some to be the greatest of all achievements in baseball. Bildner, in a prose style as easy and matter-of-fact as fielding a slow bouncer to short, tells the stories of DiMaggio and Williams in alternating sections, successfully heightening the tension as each player approaches the record. Schindler's ink, watercolor, and gouache illustrations are perfect for this light and affectionate glimpse of baseball history. Bildner doesn't assume these records will never be broken. In fact, he tells readers, "there will be another season as unforgettable as 1941," so young readers can look forward to their lives as sports fans rooting for the next baseball hero. dean Schneider
(Copyright 2011 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)